Menu of Milkhouse Diner in Marcellus, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Milkhouse Diner, nestled at 2574 Cherry Valley Turnpike in Marcellus, NY, delivers a classic diner experience with a fresh, vibrant twist. From the moment you step inside, the charming cow-themed decor sets a cozy, inviting tone, perfect for both casual breakfasts and hearty dinners.

The menu here is thoughtfully curated, blending traditional diner staples with unique, elevated options. A standout is the Eggs Benedict, priced at $12.00, which strikes a perfect balance with its silky hollandaise sauce atop perfectly poached eggs and a robust English muffin base. For those seeking a breakfast sandwich that bursts with flavor, the Farmer Breakfast Sandwich is a must-try, combining farm-fresh eggs with savory accompaniments that satisfy any morning appetite.

Sweet tooths will relish the Waffle with Chocolate Chips and Walnuts and the Blueberry Pancake, both showcasing the diner’s skill in crafting breakfast sweets that maintain a light, fluffy texture while offering rich, indulgent toppings. The Kitchen Sink Frittata is an expert blend of fresh ingredients, while the hearty Garbage Plate breakfast combo provides a generous taste of several favorites on one plate, making it perfect for those eager to sample multiple dishes at once.

On the lunch and dinner front, the Ultimate Grilled Cheese and the Patty Melt Sandwich elevate classic diner sandwiches with quality ingredients and masterful preparation. The Open-Faced Pork Belly offers a savory, rich option for those seeking depth in flavor, while the crispy Chicken Fingers paired with tangy Coleslaw remain a crowd-pleaser.

Desserts at Milkhouse Diner are not to be overlooked. The Fried Cheesecake is decadently crisp outside, creamy inside, and pairs beautifully with the Milkhouse Brookie Sundae. The Tres Leches Cake adds a touch of Latin American flair, while traditional Pie Slices and creamy Root Beer Floats bring nostalgic comfort to the table. Customer experiences highlight the exceptional homemade banana cream pie, a testament to the diner’s dedication to fresh, made-from-scratch sweets.

Service here matches the quality of the menu. Reviewers frequently commend the friendliness and attentiveness of staff like Dan and Harleigh, who provide efficient, warm hospitality that makes every visit feel personal. The option to pay by scanning the receipt at the table adds a modern convenience without compromising the down-to-earth atmosphere.

Overall, Milkhouse Diner offers more than just meals—it serves a well-rounded experience of genuine hospitality, classic diner charm, and culinary craftsmanship. Whether you’re indulging in a perfectly balanced Eggs Benedict or savoring a slice of freshly baked pie, this diner is a shining example of how tradition and innovation can harmonize on a plate.